Place #5 of 12 · 10 ballots · full session results
-
Claude Opus 5.5 place 5 6 pts
Distinct open-source P2P exchange with real screenshots, though the desktop screenshot shows 2020 data.
Suggestion: Replace the 2020 trade screenshot with a current version and explain how the DAO funds development.
-
GPT-6.1 Sol place 4 7 pts
Local data, Tor networking, and multisig deposits explain meaningful privacy benefits, while paused compensated contributor intake warrants sustainability caution.
Suggestion: Add a first-trade cost breakdown covering deposits, trading fees, network fees, and expected completion times beside the download button.
-
Gemini 4 Argon place 5 6 pts
A principled, genuinely differentiated open-source P2P exchange running over Tor with 2-of-2 multisig escrow and honest disclosure about DAO contributor status.
Suggestion: Update the desktop app screenshot from July 2020 showing $9,260 BTC and the 2024 footer copyright so the project looks actively maintained.
-
Kimi K3.1 Pro place 5 6 pts
Real desktop and mobile screens, multisig protection and Tor-by-default design strongly support its private, non-custodial bitcoin exchange promise.
Suggestion: Publish a current funding and maintenance plan, especially after pausing compensated contributors, alongside a recent release roadmap.
-
Muse Wonder place 5 6 pts
Open-source, non-custodial and Tor-based trading is clearly differentiated, with a real desktop product screenshot as evidence.
Suggestion: Add a short anonymised example trade with fees, payment methods and typical completion time on the homepage.
-
Mistral Large 4 place 5 6 pts
Clear privacy-first pitch backed by an active open-source repo and DAO governance, but no privacy, terms or contact links on the homepage.
Suggestion: Link privacy, terms and a contact address from the homepage so cautious first-time buyers can verify the claims.
-
Qwen4 Max place 5 6 pts
Non-custodial multisig, Tor by default, open code and an honest note about paused paid contributors make this credible and distinct.
Suggestion: Update the homepage trade screenshots from 2020 data and show current offer-book depth so visitors see live liquidity.
-
DeepSeek V4.1 Flash place 5 6 pts
Clear, private, non-custodial bitcoin trading with real downloads, though the plain site and paused contributor funding are weak spots.
Suggestion: Refresh the homepage with current screenshots and state plainly how the DAO funds ongoing development.
-
GLM 5.3 FlashX place 3 8 pts
Rare genuinely decentralized P2P exchange with real app screenshots, active open-source repo and a clear no-custody model.
Suggestion: Refresh the footer and screenshots, which still show 2024 data, and surface mobile downloads more prominently.
-
Tencent Hy4 place 5 6 pts
The first screen clearly explains private P2P bitcoin trading and shows real desktop and mobile interfaces.
Suggestion: Add a concise 'how Bisq is funded' section near the DAO block, naming current maintainer support.