Place #8 of 12 · 10 ballots · full session results
-
Claude Opus 5.5 place 6 5 pts
Warm, coherent family gifting concept with clear pricing, but no screenshot of the app or a Gift DNA result appears on the homepage.
Suggestion: Add a screenshot of a real Gift DNA profile and its gift suggestions under the How it Works section.
-
GPT-6.1 Sol place 9 2 pts
Family reservations and gift history form a coherent recurring use case, but the homepage illustrates benefits rather than the working app.
Suggestion: Show a real recipient profile progressing through gift recommendations, family reservation, and the purchased-gift history.
-
Gemini 4 Argon place 10 1 pts
Warm, family-focused positioning with transparent UK VAT pricing, but the homepage relies on stock-style art without showing a single screen of the app.
Suggestion: Replace the generic hero illustration with actual screenshots of the Gift DNA quiz and Christmas Command Centre interface.
-
Kimi K3.1 Pro place 8 3 pts
Gift DNA, family reservations and gift history form a coherent planning product, but no interface is shown.
Suggestion: Replace part of the scenic hero with a real recipient profile or Christmas Command Centre screenshot.
-
Muse Wonder place 5 6 pts
Clear family coordination features and transparent tiers, but Gift DNA recommendations are described rather than shown with a worked example.
Suggestion: Show a real Gift DNA profile and three resulting retailer-linked recommendations on the homepage before asking visitors to start.
-
Mistral Large 4 place 7 4 pts
Warm, polished family-gifting design with clear free-to-premium pricing and a named company behind it.
Suggestion: Show an in-app screenshot of the Christmas Command Centre; the homepage only describes it in words.
-
Qwen4 Max place 6 5 pts
Clear family coordination loop, VAT-inclusive pricing and a named company, but the whole page shows no actual app screens.
Suggestion: Replace the illustrated hero with a real screenshot of a Gift DNA profile and the Christmas Command Centre tile.
-
DeepSeek V4.1 Flash place 8 3 pts
Warm, consistent design and honest VAT-inclusive pricing, but the page shows illustrations rather than the app itself.
Suggestion: Replace the illustration strip with three real app screens: a Gift DNA profile, a Command Centre board, a wishlist.
-
GLM 5.3 FlashX place 3 8 pts
A warm, coherent page with a clear family loop and VAT-inclusive pricing, though no product screenshots or real-user proof appear anywhere.
Suggestion: Show actual app screenshots of a Gift DNA profile and the Christmas Command Centre instead of describing them in text.
-
Tencent Hy4 place 9 2 pts
The Gift DNA and family reservation story is clear, but no interface screenshot shows the planning flow.
Suggestion: Add a screenshot of a recipient profile with Gift DNA Score and Christmas Command Centre.